| 7:30pm | Perform song | Winter Wonderland (C) | 3 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 7:33pm | Perform song | Jingle Bell Rock (F) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 7:35pm | Perform song | Carol of the Bells (A) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 7:37pm | Perform song | | 5 | | Aryelle's Quartet (1 song) |
| 7:42pm | Perform song | Childrens' Medley (F) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 7:44pm | Perform song | Still Still (C) | 3 | Susan McMurray | HDH |
| 7:47pm | Perform song | A Carol Medley (F) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH + Guest Chorus |
| 7:49pm | Perform song | White Christmas (B♭) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH + Guest Chorus |
| 7:51pm | Perform song | We Wish You A Merry Christmas (F) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH + Guest Chorus |
| 7:53pm | Perform song | | 5 | | Sierra Sirens (2 songs) |
| 7:58pm | Perform song | Jingle Bells (OLD) (E) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 8:00pm | Perform song | Hark the Herald Angels Sing (E♭) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 8:02pm | Perform song | | 10 | | Ransom Notes (2 songs) |
| 8:12pm | Perform song | Trickle Trickle (F) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 8:14pm | Perform song | When You Wish Upon A Star (A) | 2 | Amy Fleming | HDH |
| 8:16pm | Perform song | Auld Lang Syne (old) (E♭) | 3 | Kimberley Halen | HDH |
| 8:19pm | Perform song | (20th Show) Let There Be Peace On Earth (B♭) | 2 | Kristin Bradshaw | HDH |
